Skip to the main content.

What does it mean to be Donor-First?

Learn More

Most Popular eBooks:

5 Powerful Ways to Increase Online Giving

This eBook teaches you the D.O.N.O.R. First Fundraising secrets that our customers are using to raise 2x the industry benchmark each year.

10 Simple Truths About Digital Fundraising
Our data-packed ebook showcases the critical need for an optimized, Donor-First Fundraising approach and where so many nonprofits are getting it wrong.

Login for iDonate Customers

Customer Login

Donor "Self-Serve" Portal

Donor Login

3 min read

Why Younger Donors Aren’t Donating Their “Stuff”

Why Younger Donors Aren’t Donating Their “Stuff”

We all know the importance (and difficulty) of connecting with younger donors, but there might be some very simple things your organization can do to expand that base and deepen existing relationships. Let’s look at some statistics that make this interesting.

Broadly speaking, donors give two types of things: money and noncash goods (or "stuff" as we'll call it). Over 60% report making monetary donations, and nearly 60% report giving stuff. And as you’d probably expect, the percentage of both categories rises steadily with age. What’s interesting is the gap between donation types for the different generations.

Among Millennial (Gen Y) givers, the difference between monetary donations and noncash gifts is two times larger than it is in Baby Boomers and Matures. And the difference is four times larger among Millennials than it is in the generation that’s closest to it in age – Gen X.

An obvious reason for this difference might be that a person collects more stuff as they grow older, so they probably have more things they’re willing to part with. And if the numbers above reflected the dollar amount of goods donated, then that might be the only explanation we’d need. But we’re talking about a majority of Millennial donors not donating any noncash item, when chances are pretty good that most of them have an electronic device or household item of value just sitting in a desk drawer or perhaps in the trunk of their car. Noncash items also include stocks and cryptocurrency, both of which have the potential for high value, but aren't typically donated because many just don't know how.

Let’s explore a few of the things that might be holding them back.

Donating Stuff Is Not an Option

Until recently, receiving a noncash gift online wasn’t a widely available option for most nonprofits. While younger donors are open to receiving communication from nonprofits via direct mail and other channels, they still prefer to respond online. So even if a nonprofit is able to take in certain types of noncash gifts through an offline channel, younger donors are less likely to respond that way.

If you’re looking to increase the number of Gen Y donors making noncash gifts, start by making it easy for them to give their stuff online.

They’re Not Aware

What items are accepted? What’s needed? Just as lots of people across the country still don’t understand which items belong in which recycling bin, many don’t understand which items can be donated either. Of course, this will vary from organization to organization, but how many clicks on your website does it take for someone to find out what types of noncash gifts you accept? Does that information exist in an accessible and helpful format?

Here’s some information you might consider providing to potential donors:

  • Acceptable methods of getting their gifts to you
  • Examples of common items you do and don’t accept
  • Tax receipt information
  • A web form or a phone number where they can ask more detailed questions about what’s accepted

They Don't See the Value

What really happens to the things they donate? You can take items to your local Goodwill drop-off center and assume something good will happen with them. But the specifics are vague. The feeling as you’re driving away is typically one of “Great, I finally got rid of that couch!” not “I’m so glad I was able to help provide a meal for someone in my community.” In other words, it’s not a warm-and-fuzzy experience. It’s a transaction of convenience.

People’s donations of goods have some cash equivalency to your organization. Helping them see that, whether it’s through an infographic or a short video, can go a long way in communicating that just as a monetary donation directly supports your cause, the donation of a good has the same tangible impact.

Nonprofit organizations have an opportunity to close the gap between cash and noncash gifts from young donors. There are a number of immediate benefits to this opportunity, but closing this gap becomes even more important when you think about the effect it could have down the road, as more and more of an individual’s wealth moves into noncash assets. Getting donors accustomed to a holistic ask from the beginning means they’ll be more likely to think of your organization as a place where they can use their wealth, not just their cash.

The Case for Ending Giving Tuesday

The Case for Ending Giving Tuesday

There is a marked decline in charitable giving among the general population. While this has been offset in dollar terms by steadily larger gifts from...

Read More
Marketing Matching Gifts Ahead of Giving Tuesday

Marketing Matching Gifts Ahead of Giving Tuesday

Marketing Matching Gifts Ahead of Giving Tuesday More than likely, your organization is already gearing up for a successful Giving Tuesday campaign...

Read More
7 Ways the Next Generation of Giving Will Look Dramatically Different

7 Ways the Next Generation of Giving Will Look Dramatically Different

The challenges today’s nonprofit leaders face are well documented — from the persistent hurdles to acquiring new donors to issues of retention....

Read More